Are you struggling with breastfeeding? Nipple shields can provide a lifeline, but choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. This comprehensive guide reviews six popular brands – Mammoth, Lansinoh, Maymom, Ardo, Medela, and Purifyou – to help you navigate the world of nipple shields and find the perfect fit for you and your baby. We'll delve into the unique features of each brand, comparing shape, material, size, hole configuration, and milk flow rate to clarify which shield might best address your specific breastfeeding challenges.From the naturally contoured Mammoth and Lansinoh shields to the longer Maymom and faster-flowing Ardo and Medela options, we'll highlight the pros and cons of each. We'll also explore the ultra-soft Purifyou shield, ideal for sensitive nipples and slower feeders. This guide aims to empower you with the knowledge needed to make an informed decision and ultimately, support a successful breastfeeding journey. Remember to consult with a lactation consultant for personalized advice.
Pros And Cons
- Softest silicone
- Most give and stretchiness
- Slowest flow (three holes, widely spaced)
- Cherry shape (more natural)
- Shortest length
- Firmest plastic
- Available in small size for smaller nipples (17-19mm)
- Similar shape to Mammoth
- Softer silicone than Mammoth
- Longest length (good for long nipples or those that stretch)
- Fairly soft silicone
- Slower flow than Mammoth (smaller holes)
Read more: 5 Best Vented Baby Bottle Nipples
Mammoth Nipple Shields: The Cherry Shape
The Mammoth nipple shield boasts a unique 'cherry' shape, designed to mimic the natural form of the nipple. This natural contour is comfortable for both mother and baby. Available in small and medium sizes, the small size is ideal for smaller nipples (17-19 millimeters) or premature babies with smaller mouths. The firm plastic construction provides excellent support.
A key feature is its shorter length compared to other brands. This shorter length can be beneficial for those with shorter nipples or who experience significant nipple stretching during feeding or pumping. The small size features closely spaced holes for controlled milk flow.
Similar Options: Lansinoh and Differences in Flow Rate
The Lansinoh nipple shield shares the same cherry shape as the Mammoth, but is made from slightly softer silicone. While I don't have a Lansinoh shield to show here, its longer length is a key differentiator. Both brands offer a similar flow rate due to their four-hole design.
The placement of the holes also impacts milk flow; the smaller Mammoth size has holes positioned closer together, potentially offering a slower flow compared to the medium Mammoth or Lansinoh. Choosing between these similar options comes down to personal preference for silicone firmness and length.
Maymom Nipple Shields: The Square Shape
The Maymom nipple shield stands out with its unique, more square shape. This is the longest shield among those reviewed and is ideal for mothers with longer nipples or those who experience significant stretching. The soft silicone material provides a comfortable fit.
Despite the four holes, the smaller hole size results in a slower milk flow rate compared to the Mammoth. The increased length of this shield is a major advantage for those with longer nipples or who find other brands inadequate.
Ardo and Medela: The Conical Shape
Both Ardo and Medela nipple shields feature a conical or cone shape. This design is common among hospital-provided shields, as Medela is a major supplier to hospitals. The Ardo shield, in particular, has five holes, resulting in a faster milk flow rate than the four-hole Mammoth or Maymom.
The Ardo's larger size is evident when compared to the Maymom. The faster flow rate can be advantageous for mothers with overactive let-downs or babies who need a quicker milk supply. Mothers who need a faster flow would find the Ardo useful.
Purifyou Nipple Shields: Softest Silicone and Slowest Flow
The Purifyou nipple shield, purchased from Amazon, is characterized by its incredibly soft silicone material, providing maximum flexibility and stretch. This softness is beneficial for those with sensitive nipples.
However, its three widely spaced holes result in the slowest flow rate among the shields reviewed. This is particularly beneficial for babies with high palates, tongue ties, or those who prefer a slower, more controlled feeding experience. This would be suitable for babies with a slower feeding pace.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Nipple Shield
The choice of nipple shield depends heavily on individual needs and preferences. Consider nipple size, baby's mouth size, latch difficulties, milk flow rate, and any underlying issues like tongue-tie or high palate. The Mammoth offers a firm, natural shape; Maymom provides a longer length; Ardo and Medela offer faster flow; and Purifyou offers maximum softness and a slow flow.
Always consult with a lactation consultant to address any breastfeeding challenges and to help you determine the best course of action for a healthy and successful breastfeeding journey. Don't hesitate to experiment with different brands to find the perfect fit.